Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Financing Your ADU

There are two main barriers for homeowners who wish to build an accessory dwelling unit. One barrier is zoning and building codes. In many municipalities, due to existing building, planning, or zoning ordinances, ADUs simply aren’t allowed. 

The other barrier, which is equally formidable to those who live in places that DO allow ADUs, is the capital cost required to build an ADU. Many homeowners are intrigued by the idea of building an ADU, but financing an ADU in real life is daunting. This post is a detailed exploration of costs, funding approaches, and other options that you can consider in order to fund ADU construction. 

As I’ve written about in a previous post, my personal top priority for this project was to create a financially sustainable living situation. I see ADU’s as a very sustainable way to reduce living expenses, and even a way to generate significant income. However, the initial expense was a formidable barrier for me, as it is for everyone. Case in point: I estimate that my project will end up costing about $92K; you can read more about that cost breakdown.


How much does it cost to build a custom ADU?

Design/build cost for new construction ranges between $100-175/sq ft for a small, fully livable dwelling unit. For an 800 sq ft ADU, one should count on spending $80-140K, depending on the style of construction.  

For the purpose of this blog post, let’s say that we plan to build a 400 sq ft ADU. At $100/sq ft, we'd only spend have to spend $40K. However, smaller structures tend to cost more per square foot. For a 400 sq ft ADU, you should count on paying closer to $125-$200 per sq ft (aka. $50K-80K).

This increased cost is due in part to fixed costs. For example, no matter how small the structure that you’re building, you’re probably going to have to pay at least ~$5K just for plumbing, $5K for electrical and $3-5K for a permit. For a 400 sq ft ADU, you man end up spending almost as much on plumbing, electrical, and permit as one would spend designing/building a 2000 sq ft house.  My point is that you'll save money on most of your costs by building smaller, but there is a diminishing return on building smaller in terms of savings. 

Major Design Considerations that Significantly Reduce Design/Build Cost: 

  • The cost for pre-fabricated houses is considerably less than custom new construction. Here’s an example of very pretty prefabricated cottages that start at $14K. I don’t know how to permit a prefabricated cottage as an ADU, but this seems to be a viable ADU design option to pursue if you’re on a very tight budget. Also, consider “tiny houses” or trailers if your budget is limited to about $10K.
  • You can save big dollars if you build a “detached bedroom” or structure under 200 sq ft that does not require its own plumbing or kitchen. If you are just looking to expand the livable space of your property to build a guestroom or office, you can dramatically reduce your projects costs by simply not constructing an "Accessory Dwelling Unit". In Portland, structures under 200 sq ft don't even need to be permitted. However, such structures also not supposed to have basic building services that do require permits, such electrical, plumbing, or heat. Plenty of people reside in such structures though.
  • Obviously, the more labor that you do not pay others to do for you, the lower your total design/build costs will be. I’ll cover this in much more depth below.
  • According to one builder and an article that I have read on the matter, the costs for converting an existing garage are approximately the same cost per square foot as new construction (depending on the condition of the foundation and structure). Building an ADU from an interior carve out or bump out from an existing house, basement, or attic, are considerably less expensive than a standalone detached ADU. 
Building a Non-Permitted ADU:

In Portland, you can count on paying between $3-6K for an ADU permit. Nationally, where ADUs are allowed, permit fees will vary greatly by municipal and county jurisdiction. Portland has conventionally required System Development Charges for ADUs, which typically cost about $10K. However, through June 30th, 2013, Portland has waived System Development Charges for ADUs as a regulatory incentive to promote ADUs. You can read the City of Portland’s full stately and elegant policy statement about this issue here (I think it’s a great read, actually).


Non-permitted ADUs are cheaper to build. There are major drawbacks to building without permits,  but I understand why people would choose this option. A single conversation with a city planning officer, who tells you that you can not build where you would like to build, or that you would need to replace what you thought was a perfectly solid foundation in order to build a permit-able ADU, may be enough to spur you to bypass the permitting process altogether. 

In fact, one local study of MLS listing descriptions indicated that only 38% of ADUs in Portland were actually permitted -- most of the ADUs in Portland have not been built to code nor permitted. So, if you choose to go this route, you're not alone. And, where ADU's aren't allowed by code, you may feel that building without permits is the only option available to you. Interestingly, Tiny Houses were born as a smaller dwelling option that exploited a regulatory loophole that allows smaller, accessory houses---as long as they're on wheels.


Financing Options

1) Savings and Liquid Assets

The easiest and best way to finance an ADU is with pre-existing savings, but most of us don’t have $50-200K cash to spare. But, think it over. Maybe you have a retirement savings 401K plan against which you can borrow cash. Others may consider selling stocks other property to generate sufficient capital. And, some people may have family or relatives who are willing to loan you money at a low interest rate. 

Remember that even a 3% interest “family-loan” rate is a better rate that most retirees can reliably get for their retirement savings in this sluggish market, so this investment loan may be more appealing to your endowed elders than you would think.


2) 203(K) Loan


For those who are purchasing a new home, consider wrapping an ADU construction loan into your mortgage. FHA 203(k) loans are intended for people who are buying a home and want to make repairs and renovations to the property.  The program is supposed to help revitalize/rejuvenate the country's existing housing stock.

The rules for 203(k) loan projects that can qualify are a bit vague.  The rules do say that you must rehab an "existing dwelling" but they also say that you can buy a house, raze it and use the program to build a new house as long as you use some of the existing foundation.  So it's not really written with ADU's in mind, but it seems you can get an ADU project to qualify if you have an existing structure like a garage that you're going to "convert".  

Some banks who want to sell these loans have decided to read the FHA rules in a way that makes ADU projects possible, and then they ask an FHA underwriter to review site plans on a case by case basis.  Some loan officers at some banks that will tell you that you can't build an ADU using the 203(k) program.  Some loan officers are  on the opposite side, actively trying to sell the loans to people who want to build ADU's.

203(k) loans take a lot of planning and work up front. The bank tells you that from the day you have an accepted offer on the house, you have 30 days to submit to them all of the paperwork necessary for them to order an appraisal for the whole (house plus ADU) property. That means, in those 30 days, you need to be able to submit a full bid for the construction, down to some fairly detailed items like what  type of flooring, countertops, appliances, paint, windows, doors, etc.  Basically, they want to know everything about the ADU so they can value it accurately.  Once you submit all of the required forms you're required to work with an FHA Consultant, who has FHA forms to fill out with all of the specifications and expected costs on a line item basis), the bank orders the appraisal, and then your loan processing starts and will be complete in another 30 days.  So it's a total 60 day closing period (minimum).  So you need to have a seller that's okay with that time frame.   

This loan could potentially work if you could use part of an existing structure to make an ADU.  So, this low interest federal loan option is great to consider if you are buying a new house, are already eligible for a 203(k) loan (check with your loan officer), and are interesting in converting part of your house or converting your garage to an ADU.


3) Refinancing An Existing House


Refinancing a home to help you finance an ADU may be a good option to consider if you already have substantial equity in an existing house and the payback calculations for an ADU work out in your favor. And, refinancing has fewer strings attached to it than construction loans.


4) Remodel Construction Loan


Very few banks have taken this step, but according to this article in the Daily Journal of Commerce, at least Washington Federal has made the logical leap to giving out remodel loans for ADU construction. Here’s Washington Federal guidance about their “All in One” loans

In general, the difficulty with construction loans is that their rules are more strict, the interest rates are higher, and banks don’t know how to accurately evaluate the value of ADUs yet, so banks are reluctant to give a loan out that assumes a particular dollar value for them.  


5) Live-Work Trade


This next idea is a great option for younger homeowners with relatively little financial capital, and who have talented builder friends. There’s plenty of ways that a live work trade could be structured. If you’re planning on using the ADU as a income generating guest house, you may be able to figure out a fair way to split the costs with relative or friend, making them an business partner in your micro-venture. Here’s one example of a work-trade arrangement: 

Someone I know built a beautiful detached living space in Portland. Simultaneously, he also built a new bathroom and kitchen attached to an existing garage. The detatched bedroom has close, convenient, and private access to both amenities, although it is not physically connected. This detached bedroom structure is approximately 200sq ft, and the materials for the kitchen, bathroom, and detatched structure cost about $15K. He worked with a builder on this project for a year, and rather than paying the builder with cash, the builder had free rent in the bedroom for a three year period, which they valued at $30K. $30K is the amount that he would have paid the builder if he paid the builder with cash instead of free rent for three years. 

This project is about 320sq ft, and cost about $45K (~$140 sq ft). However, because of the live work trade arrangement, and the lack of permit fees beause it isn’t considered an ADU, the whole project only cost him $15K in cash.

This kind of bartering arrangement is wonderful, and indeed, can work out to be very favorably for all parties financially, personally, and professionally. One drawback is that the ADU is not going to generate any income for the homeowner for three years. And, the builder is going to living on their property, which may not be an option for many homeowners. But, if you don’t have access to a lot of capital, a live/work trade option may be the be right option for you.  

As another benefit, since both the homeowner and the builder were very personally invested in how the project came out, the structure came out looking gorgeous.

How to Lower the Design/Build Cost of Your ADU through Time, Labor, and Materials

The amount of work that the homeowner does in designing/building an ADU will vary from none of the work, to all of the work. I suspect that most homeowners who are designing/building a custom ADU are going to want to be at least a little bit involved in the design process, if not the building process. 

Personally, after much debate, I contracted out the majority of the work up to the final stage of construction. Initially, I wanted to do the work myself, but I realized that most of the work beyond my capacity. I could have helped as a laborer if I had more free time, but I could not have constructed the project on my own. However, I will be doing the ‘finish work’, including the hardwood flooring, the kitchen and bathroom, and the painting.

I spent roughly 33% on purely material costs (such as wood, siding, concrete, paint, and appliances) and about 66% purely on labor costs. Labor for new construction in the United States is not simple nor cheap. But, if one had the know-how to do all of this work themself (including electrical and plumbing), and a year of time to put into it, one could have do this job on their own for just the material costs (ie. $30K, as opposed to my projected cost of $92K). 

Furthermore, with enough time and building knowledge, it would be conceivable to source many of the materials that were needed through Craigslist and other building material resellers and design the project partially around those materials. 

For example, I paid $3K for 15 new windows. I think it is possible to acquire 15 wonderful, unused windows for as little as $1000. However, it would be impossible to get a particular kind of window, with say, specific height and widths, or Energy Star specifications. But, if the homeowner is VERY flexible about what materials they use, has ample time to source and collect those building materials, they could cut material costs by possibly 30-50%. It is conceivable that with sufficient time and flexibility, I could have acquired usable building materials for as little as $15-20K (as opposed to $30K, a $10-15K savings)

The most practical way to source used materials for an ADU would be to collect building materials over time, and design a house using those materials. Some of the building materials would necessarily have to purchased new. For example, if you need to pour a concrete foundation, you would have purchase new concrete. If your project will be inspected, you would need to use many new materials. For example, due to inspections, I need to have new light fixtures with the UL stickers still on them, instead of reusing light fixtures as I had originally planning. And just inexpensive light fixtures, I had to pay nearly $700. 

In summary, if I did all of the work myself, including all of the highly skilled trades of architecture, plumbing, and electrical; and had the patience and determination to build a structure over a very laborious year-long period, I believe it would be conceivable to design and build a comparable structure from mostly salvaged materials for $20K + a working year of my time.  

For me, and the vast majority of the population, this type of DIY scenario is highly unrealistic. But, for an highly skilled homeowner with a year of time at their disposal, this approach may be an option to consider. Given our nation's cultural self-reliant mentality, I am sure that this DIY approach has been used a countless number of times.  

Here's an article about "Re-Creation" house renovation project that a friend of mine built using 90% salvaged materials. As a point of reference, the mostly-used material expenses for this 640 sq ft project amounted to ~$20,500.


Calculating Payback on the ADU Capital Investment 

In my case, to fund the project, I borrowed money from my future self by borrowing against my retirement savings via my 401K. I calculated that the benefit of living mortgage-free after this project made it worth the trade-off of using my retirement funds.  

Generally speaking, financial advisers would not recommend taking money out of a retirement account. While I am paying my future back over the next 15 years, this retirement money is not going to invested in the market. It's an open question as to whether the value of real estate in Portland will increase at quicker rate than the a 401K (which mirrors the S+P 500), but the ADU investment has other financial paybacks that seem more reliable to me the S+P 500.

Upon completion of construction, I will be relatively cash poor and relatively equity rich. The primary house on the property is going to 'cash flow' as soon as I move into the ADU. This means that I anticipate that the rental income from the main house will fully cover the cost of the mortgage, interest, and taxes on the total property. If this assumption is accurate, though I won't have much money left in my bank account, I'll be in a position of relative financial freedom in the sense that I will not have to pay monthly living expenses. 

In terms of resale value, my Realtor described it to me this way. If I spent $100k on my project and assume a conservative number of $50k increased property value, the property would need to earn $50,000 before I'd break even. Conservatively assuming I rented out the ADU at $1000/month, it would take 4.2 yrs to "break-even" on the project. 

I'm guessing that, in reality, the ADU will add $100K to the assessed value of the property. If I resold the property (house and ADU) immediately upon completion this fall, I would not make much profit from this venture. However, if I were to hold onto the ADU for 10 years as a $1000/month rental property, it would generate $120,000 in rental income. The longer that I hold onto the property, the better it will work for me financially.

Personally, I don't intend to sell the property anytime soon, so at $1000/month, the payback period for $92K is 7.6 years. After 7.6 years, the investment will have paid itself back. Since I will be living in the ADU, this equation isn't actually this simple. But, for the purpose of this blog post, we can safely say that the investment pays for itself in 7.6 years or less and then generates income thereafter.


Conclusion 

To me, ADUs represent a very compelling financing investment for homeowners. But, they aren’t possible for many homeowners due to the cost barrier. There’s many factors to consider if you’re starting to get intrigued about the idea of building an ADU, but I’ll suggest that the most important factor to consider is whether/how the ADU will work out for you as a financial sustainable investment, and whether you can figure out some creative financial mechanism to overcome their formidable up front costs. Hopefully, if you're toying with the idea of building an ADU, one of the ideas listed in this blog post will help you overcome that first capital hurdle.

28 comments:

  1. My lender says that the garage has to be connected to the house in order to be able to work on it, is this your experience?

    ReplyDelete
  2. It depends on what kind of financing you're getting from your lender. 203K loans require that you do work on your existing house. I don't believe that other loans have that same caveat.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. What are the "major drawbacks" to building without a permit?

    ReplyDelete
  5. There are several. 1) Risk- if a neighbor complains, you can get a stop work order. Of, if it's already built, I don't know what they do exactly.
    2) Resale- It won't add value to your house from an appraiser's perspective, nor can the space be counted as a legal bedroom or separate unit. Thus, buyers won't be able to get financing for as much as you would like to sell it for.
    3) Building codes are there for a reason. They're annoying, but they're all there to ensure that you build a safe, habitable, structure that works with the fabric of your city.

    All this said, I don't personally have a problem with non-permitted structures. And, most ADUs aren't permitted.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The Calculating Payback section has missed a very large cost of this ADU, the opportunity cost of the invested capital. If the Author had not built the ADU her $100k would have probably earned about 10% nominal return - 2.5% inflation (it's not fair to look back and use actual market returns during this time period - she didn't know what actual returns would be at the decision point; so I used historical averages). In 5 years her $100k would have been $144k in year 0 equivalent dollars or $161k in year 5 dollars. She has not accounted for inflation in her payback analysis, so the $161k figure is the appropriate one to compare. She does not have $161k she would have had otherwise, because of her decision to build the ADU, so she should include this lost wealth in any financial analysis she uses to decide what to invest in.
    It makes the ADU decision much less lucrative in any reasonably predictable time period, and in addition, in the long run after 5 years the $161k would have continued to grow at rates likely significantly faster than rents would grow, and would not require maintenance or renter turnover costs or effort, or generate liability from tenant's legal or illegal actions. Therefore, reasons to do it that can be rationally defended are almost certainly not financial payback on rental property.
    It could be a great option if her dad dies, leaves her elderly mother in a house that is too large or too hard to maintain. In that case the large house could be sold and used to pay for the ADU. That is a scenario where it could be both financially and personally advantageous v. her mother paying for rent in an unaffiliated 3rd party rental unit farther away.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice Article Posting. Selective Financial Services applies a professional structured financial approach to project finance and commercial transactions. When raising project finance it is important to have a plan or strategy for the future of the business to show to us, or cooperating banks, funders or alternative potential lenders. Your Business Plan can take several forms depending on the business and its circumstances.

    ReplyDelete
  8. FYI: Zoe cottages mentioned as Pre-Fab possibility are a scam:

    http://www.katu.com/news/problemsolver/Tiny-houses-big-problems-255269361.html

    ReplyDelete
  9. There are significant opportunities in Finance Functions within Police Forces to be transformed from a silo based culture that focuses largely on transactional activities to a process and metric based culture equally focusing on transactional processing, management information and strategic requirements. This transformation can deliver large cost savings, service improvement and better quality, faster processing.
    home financing

    ReplyDelete
  10. maintain your drain cleaning system with proper of plumbing line you can call us :- There are so much more Plumbing leaks Denver on all times in the wait with in term based all in the plumber needs. There are many numbers for plumbers all coming up Plumber Denver all who will help in getting the work completed.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi, I'm wondering if you have any experience with creating an ADU from an existing un-permitted basement apartment.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Yes, I do. It can be done, but it can be a pain in the butt. Sometimes it's worth it, sometimes not.. I can do an on-site consult if you want me to take a look. Or, an experienced basement ADU GC would tell you about what would be required.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  14. If the only barrier in building your church is your financial limitation, don't think it as a problem. Griffin capital funding is offering some church loans throughout the country to help building church.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Really great post. I just unearthed your web journal and needed to say that I have truly delighted in perusing your blog entries. Any way I'll be subscribing to your food and I trust you post again soon. Enormous a debt of gratitude is in order for the helpful data. calgary airport renovations

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hello friends,do you have an existing business or want to start up one but need capital to do so?Contact Mr Steven Ryan Finance via this details: Email:Stevenryanfinance@gmail.com
    Whatsapp:+971529615981

    ReplyDelete
  17. This is the only loan company that i can grant you legit loan within 24 hours you can contact him for any kind of loan they are there to help you this is there direct contact Email:(Citvendorfinance@gmail .com) or whatsapp +1 (747) 223-7461

    ReplyDelete
  18. Good day everyone my name is Santiago Matías, i am a citizen of Ecuador i was seriously in need of an urgent loan to support my oil and gas company and i got my loan of $1,000,000.00 from a genuine loan lender called peter loan company. And now i'm very happy that i have finanlly raised and build up my company. If there is anyone who is also in need of an urgent loan should kindly contact peter loan company now on their Email Adress (peterloanfirmcompany112@gmail.com) or kindly whattsapp them on (+2349063879939) and get your loan now........ They do offer any types of loans to individuals, student, workers, company's owners and every other person. Do you need a loan to finance, assist and support your bussiness, pay school fees, pay bill, grow up your company, open a super market or open a bussiness center or have you been searching for loan for a very long time? kindly contact peter loan company offers now on email (peterloanfirmcompany112@gmail.com) or whattsapp them on (+2349063879939) And put an end to your broblems...... Apply now......... Get your loan immediately and celebrate with your own testimony thanks.......Best regurd.
    Remain Bless........

    ReplyDelete
  19. Are you looking for credit truth ?? Need a loan in any form and for any reason ?? We are here to help you in the end as we offer reliable lending interest rate of only 3%. Borrowers interested should contact us now at (garrywiltonloan756@gmail.com and get a loan today.
    Thank you.
    E-mail: garrywiltonloan756@gmail.com

    author Garry Wilton

    ReplyDelete
  20. Loan Opportunity Offered By Mr, Benjamin That Save My Family From Financial Bondage {lfdsloans@lemeridianfds.com}

    Hello Everyone, I am Putri Adiratnaa single mom from Jakarta, I would like to share this great testimony on how I got a loan from Mr, Benjamin, when we were driven out of our home when I couldn't pay my bills anymore, After being scammed by various companies online and denied a loan from my bank and some other credit union I visited. My children were taken by the foster care, I was all alone in the street. The day i shamefully walked into an old school mate who introduced me to Daisy Maureen. At first I told her that I am not ready to take any risk of requesting a loan online anymore, but she assured me that I will receive my loan from them. On a second thought, due to my homelessness I had to take a trial and applied for the loan, luckily for me I received a loan of $80,000.00 from Mr, Benjamin. I'm happy I took the risk and applied for the loan. My kids have been given back to me and now I own a home and a business of my own. All thanks and gratitude goes to Le_Meridian Funding Service and for the help of Mr, Benjamin for giving me a meaning to life when i had lost all hope. If you currently seeking for a loan assistance, you can contact them via: {lfdsloans@lemeridianfds.com} Or WhatsApp +1-989-394-3740

    ReplyDelete
  21. Online casinos are not as bad live22 hack tool as you think. But there are yet many good things hidden on the site.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Promote online gamblingFrom this point of view, this is a guarantee mark that the Pantip football betting 918kiss apk latest version
    website has been properly certified in accordance with foreign law.

    ReplyDelete
  23. 918kiss casino apss/
    https://apps918 ios casino
    918live game
    918kiss live apk
    live casino 918kiss
    There are good and bad examples of this Greek gambler's story. Point out that arrogance and gambling can lead to disaster unconsciously. Including cheating in casinos or using online casino programs is not a good choice. Because in today's technology, the talking face can easily catch people who do bad things. On the positive side, if $ 50 million can be turned into $ 40 million, it means that gambling is a dessert that is worth tasting. Choose to watch fun online casinos to create your own betting experience.
    http://jameson.mystrikingly.com/
    https://zatrickv.page.tl/
    https://kaprine.wixsite.com/mysite
    https://etearns.weebly.com/
    https://sites.google.com/view/georgep/home

    ReplyDelete
  24. Baccarat is unorthodox online game that is currently popular, and many people are enthusiastic in it. It has afterward become well-liked along with all baccarat formula players. Many people past it because it is a game that is easy to comprehend and simple to put-on gone real bonuses.But many people nevertheless don't know that baccarat has many formulas and behavior that can help you win baccarat. allow us know the formula that will be used to conquer Baccarat. Today we will acknowledge you to understand and comprehend this formula. The table tennis formula is substitute casino royale villa formula that gamblers in the same way as to use. For those who have never used the formula, Baccarat, let us know each other.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Great ....You have beautifully presented your acompio
    thought in this blog post. I admire the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer. acompio

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thanks for sharing such beautiful information with us. I hope you will share some more info about Financing

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...